Lets face it, Old Spice’s recent video response campaign was pretty  good. So good in fact, it garnered 40+ million views in only a few days. Since then, there are have been plenty of paradies that surfaced. Most of which consisted of random YouTubers looking to raise their view counts.

Enter Cisco SPice, a blatant rip-off of the Old Spice guy, who I now feel incredibly sorry for after watching the videos. With a mere 2,750 views on 18 videos in the first 24 hours, the campaign paled in comparison to Old Spice’s 40 million plus views.  So where did Cisco go wrong?

Cisco Didn’t Set The Stage

For starters, who the heck is Ted from accounting?  Why did Cisco wait until the day of the campaign to introduce him to us?  Old Spice’s ‘The Man Your Man Could Smell Like’ had made his way to stardom months before the response campaign began.  He was seen on television and viewed by millions on YouTube.  If people don’t know who you are then they won’t care if you make a video response about them, plain and simple.

I have a feeling that over the coming days Cisco’s campaign will start to get more coverage and people will learn about who Ted from accounting is.  Maybe if the company decides to stage another response campaign with Ted in a week or so they will get a little more of a following.  But until people get to know Ted, who he is and what he’s about, this thing isn’t going to take off.

Cisco Didn’t Optimize Their Twitter Campaign

When Old Spice began their response campaign they ran the whole thing from a single Twitter account–@OldSpice.  Fans were invited to tweet comments to this account and get updates and video links from this account.  Throughout the day, thousands upon thousands of people found out about the campaign and began following the Old Spice Twitter account.  Cisco missed out on all of this.

Cisco did not have an account for running this campaign.  Rather, they promoted the campaign from three separate Cisco Twitter accounts and asked fans to tweet comments to a hashtag and not to an actual account.  If they had created a CiscoSPice Twitter account then they could have engaged a lot more people.  Each and every person who sent a Tweet to the campaign would be promoting it, providing a link for all of their followers to go to for more information, and while they were there they may have followed too, and even sent out a Tweet of their own.  Additionally, the Cisco Twitter accounts being used to promote the campaign only have a total of just over 3,000 followers combined.

If Cisco goes forward with this project, they must make Ted from accounting a Twitter account of his own.  Give him the opportunity to promote the campaign, get some followers and fans of his own, and spread awareness for the brand.  It looks like @CiscoSpice is already taken by Cisco’s CiscoSP360 blog moderator, Don Nelson.  However, it is set to private and was not used in this campaign.

Cisco Didn’t Copy Enough From The Old Spice Campaign

“Look at your router, now back at mine, now back at your router, now back at mine.  Sadly it isn’t a Cisco.”

Cisco copied the Old Spice campaign in two ways—they’ve got a man standing in a bathroom with a towel around his waist, and they are creating response videos to specific users on the Web.  However, they neglected to use any of the funny lines or ideas from the successful Old Spice campaign.  If you are going to copy somebody else’s work, you might as well go all the way with it.

Also, where is Ted from accounting’s video response to the man who started it all—the man your man could smell like?  By bringing the Old Spice guy into the mix, Cisco could have drummed up a lot more press for the campaign and maybe even gotten a shout-out from Old Spice on Twitter.  Who knows?